CO129-080 - Sir Robinson - 1861 [1-3] — Page 524

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

the inconveniences

The Secretary of State for the Colonies

inconveniences resulting from the reservation of so many isolated sites for Batteries which in many cases are a great obstruction to the develop-

ment of the Colony and in my opinion many of them

may be dispensed with, not only for the advantages which would accrue to the Colony but for the

purpose of more effective arrange-

ment and concentration.

I am sure it will be admitted that Hong Kong Harbour without the assistance of the Navy is indefensible against any regularly equipped European fleet; and I am aware the late Right Honorable the Secretary of State for War was of opinion that the object to be sought in any defence of the Harbour and Colony was such a disposition of a few effective

Batteries as would prevent any sudden descent upon the Colony

of a flying Squadron of two or three Ships.

I have lately perused the Par-

liamentary Paper Military Defences

(Colonies) and I am now convinced than ever that remonstrances originally made against the reservation of such a variety of points on the Island for small detached Batteries were justifiable and such reservation I submit is clearly recognised, in the Paper referred to, as defective in principle and objectionable in the highest degree.

I cannot better exemplify the position I wish to bring to the notice of His Excellency than by enclosing for his consideration a Plan of the Island, Kowloon and Stone Cutter's Island, showing the

several

Edit History

2026-05-18 22:37:56 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
the inconveniences The Secretary of State for the Colonies inconveniences resulting from the reservation of so many isolated sites for Batteries which in many cases are a great obstruction to the develop- ment of the Colony and in my opinion many of them may be dispensed with, not only for the advantages which would accrue to the Colony but for the purpose of more effective arrange- ment and concentration. I am sure it will be admitted that Hong Kong Harbour without the assistance of the Navy is indefensible against any regularly equipped European fleet; and I am aware the late Right Honorable the Secretary of State for War was of opinion that the object to be sought in any defence of the Harbour and Colony was such a disposition of a few effective Batteries as would prevent any sudden descent upon the Colony of a flying Squadron of two or three Ships. I have lately perused the Par- liamentary Paper Military Defences (Colonies) and I am now convinced than ever that remonstrances originally made against the reservation of such a variety of points on the Island for small detached Batteries were justifiable and such reservation I submit is clearly recognised, in the Paper referred to, as defective in principle and objectionable in the highest degree. I cannot better exemplify the position I wish to bring to the notice of His Excellency than by enclosing for his consideration a Plan of the Island, Kowloon and Stone Cutter's Island, showing the several
Baseline (Original)
ار the inconveniences The Secretary of State for the Colonies anveniences resulting from the reservation of so many isolated sites for Batteries which in many cases are a great obstruction to the develop. may ment of the files and in my opinion - many of them be dispensed with, not only for he advantages which I would accrue to the fity but for the purpose of more effective arrange. ment and concentration. I am sure it will be admitted that Hongseong Harbour without the assistance of the Navy is indefensible against any regularly equipped European fleet; and I am aware the late Right Honorable the Secretary of State for War was of opinion that the object to be sought in any defence of the Harbour and fity was such a disposition of a few effective effective Batteries as would prevent any sudden descent upon the fity of a flying Squadron of two or three Ships. I have lately perused the Par - liamentary Paper Military Defences am now more con (Colonies) and I am now vinced than ever that remonstrances originally made against the reservation of such a varietes of points on the Island for small detached, Batteries were justifiable and such reservation I submit is clearly recognised, in the Paper referred to, as defective in principle and objectionable in the highest degree. I cannot better exemplify the position I wish to bring to the notice of His Excellency than by enclosing for his consideration a Han of the Island, Nowloon and Stone cutter's island, showing the several
2026-05-18 22:37:56 · Baseline
View content

ار

the inconveniences

The Secretary of State for the Colonies

anveniences resulting from the reservation of so many isolated sites for Batteries which in many cases are a great obstruction to the develop.

may

ment of the files and in my opinion - many of them

be dispensed with, not only for he advantages which I would accrue to the fity but for the

purpose of

more

effective arrange.

ment and concentration.

I am sure it will be admitted that Hongseong Harbour without the assistance of the Navy is indefensible against any regularly equipped European fleet; and I am aware the late Right Honorable the Secretary of State for War was of opinion that the object to be sought in any defence of the Harbour and fity was such a disposition of a few effective

effective Batteries as would prevent any sudden descent upon the fity

of a flying Squadron of two or three Ships.

I have lately perused the Par - liamentary Paper Military Defences

am now more con

(Colonies) and I am now vinced than ever that remonstrances originally made against the reservation of such a varietes of points on the Island for small detached, Batteries were justifiable and such reservation I submit is clearly recognised, in the Paper referred to, as defective in principle and objectionable in the highest degree.

I cannot better exemplify the position I wish to bring to the notice of His Excellency than by enclosing for his consideration a Han of the Island, Nowloon and Stone cutter's island, showing the

several

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.